Are New Executive Condos Still For The “Sandwich Class” In Singapore?

Get The Property Insights Serious Buyers Read First: Join 50,000+ readers who rely on our weekly breakdowns of Singapore’s property market.

A seasoned content strategist with over 17 years in the real estate and financial journalism sectors, Ryan has built a reputation for transforming complex industry jargon into accessible knowledge. With a track record of writing and editing for leading financial platforms and publications, Ryan's expertise has been recognised across various media outlets. His role as a former content editor for 99.co and a co-host for CNA 938's Open House programme underscores his commitment to providing valuable insights into the property market.
Is there even a point to the Executive Condominium (EC) scheme anymore?
I know this will ruffle some feathers, but it’s time we gave this some thought. The EC scheme, which dates back to 1995, was designed as a form of sandwich-class housing: a home for those who earned too much to buy a regular flat, but too little to buy private housing. But the recent dynamite performance of Hundred Palms EC, along with the rising cost and quality of new ECs, suggests some rethinking might be in order.
First, it may be time to ponder if like Central area BTO flats before Plus and Prime – ECs have become more of a lottery ticket than genuine sandwich housing.
From interactions on the ground, it’s clear to me that no small number of buyers see ECs as a waiting windfall: assuming you can get one, it’s sure to go up in price in the short span of just five years. Hundred Palms is the most recent example, but check out some of the gains we’re seeing. The fact is, buyers who expect their ECs to be windfalls are seldom disappointed – and this explains why almost every EC sells fast, including Aurelle of Tampines quite recently.
So in principle, we’re already running a bit contrary to the original intent of sandwich housing.
Then there’s the issue of how affordable an EC is these days.
As I’ve mentioned before, buyers who are at or below the $16,000 per month income ceiling for ECs probably have to make a bigger down payment. To quickly repeat: the MSR of the home loan cannot exceed 30 per cent of your monthly income. So at the ceiling of $16,000 per month, the maximum home loan repayment is about $4,800 per month, which caps the loan amount to $910,000.
Assuming a three-bedder at Aurelle is around $1.689 million (indicative), you would need to borrow $1.26 million+ to make the minimum down payment of 25 per cent. So buyers are going to have to cover a shortfall. Raising the income ceiling would fix that, but it would still be a sign that our EC prices are getting on the high side.
If we’re still committed to the idea of ECs as housing first, albeit sandwich housing, we have to be careful that we don’t neglect affordability. Something that’s misleadingly easy to do, because of the temptation to handwave it and say they can “go buy a resale flat” instead.
Let’s not forget the price gap with private condos either
When we checked last year, the price gap between resale ECs and condos is still there (whew!), but as we mentioned, the coming of higher-end ECs may bring a change (I mentioned this regarding Aurelle in the linked article). Barring the largest units like five-bedders, the price gap between an EC and a private condo has generally narrowed in the past three years.
But this could be the start of an unwanted trend: as more expensive new ECs hit the market, and resale gains start climbing, we may soon see the two segments nearing in price (e.g., Hundred Palms’ $3 million+ transaction). As the gap narrows further, the question of ECs’ relevance as “sandwich housing” will come into further question.
To be fair, the high prices do match the better quality we’re seeing – but this further differentiates the EC concept today from yesteryears
I’m not going to point at any specific projects and affect property values here, but since around 2017 (the last land cycle), EC quality has jumped tremendously – a change that may also explain the higher prices.
Earlier batches of ECs were quite different: ask agents or buyers in the past, and most will affirm that ECs used to mean:
More from Stacked
We analysed 87 en bloc condos. Here’s what we learnt.
En bloc condos were all the rage in 2017 and 2018, which isn't surprising at all given that you could…
- A very inaccessible location, far from the MRT station
- Cramped or closely packed blocks
- Lower quality finishing
- Facilities that are smaller or limited than a fully private condo
This is no longer the case today. Recent launches like Novo Place, Aurelle, etc. have layouts, facilities, and finishing that are on par with fully private counterparts. I’ve actually tried asking people on the ground to spot the EC versus the private condo, from the project details and pictures. Barely a third of the people I ask can tell the difference (and I suspect some of them were just lucky guessers.)
This may lead to a further narrowing of price gaps over time. Some examples of this can already be seen in the Punggol area:
Prive, an EC in Punggol, is fetching average prices of $1,455 psf; and yet River Isles, a fully private condo also in Punggol, currently averages $1,444 psf. There’s an interesting transaction to note here:
In February 2025, a 1,173 sq.ft. unit at River Isles transacted for $1.7 million. But a month earlier Prive EC saw a slightly smaller unit (1,087 sq.ft.) transact for a slightly higher $1.72 million!
The Prive transaction also very nearly beat A Treasure Trove; this is a private condo in Punggol where, in February 2025, a 1,044 sq.ft. unit transacted for $1.733 million; barely higher than Prive, despite the units being almost similar in size.
We can also consider Flo Residence, another private condo in the Punggol area. Units here average $1,356 psf. This is lower than two other ECs in Punggol: The Terrace ($1,409 psf) and Twin Waterfalls ($1,489 psf).
Even if we acknowledge that factors such as floor level, facing, state of maintenance etc. play a role, these are empirical signs that the gap between ECs and condos are closing in Punggol; and other neighbourhoods may follow in time.
Whilst I do think we’ll always have and need a sandwich housing scheme, the nature of that scheme can change
We also tried once with DBSS, for example, although that didn’t last long. But I do expect that, with the way ECs are closing in on fully private counterparts – in terms of both price and quality – we might soon see some alternatives.
Meanwhile in other property news:
- Can you find an almost new three-bedder unit for under $1.5 million? Here are some possible places to check out.
- Is emptying out your CPF to pay your home loan always the best idea? It’s situational, and there are some things to consider first.
- Here’s a homeowner experience we can all relate to: wanting to keep renovation rates sane. Here’s one many of us fail to relate to: people who actually manage to do it.
- Integrated developments: love them or hate them, they’re here to stay on our ever more populated island. Here are some experiences of the people who live in them.
Weekly Sales Roundup (24 March – 30 March)
Top 5 Most Expensive New Sales (By Project)
PROJECT NAME | PRICE S$ | AREA (SQFT) | $PSF | TENURE |
32 GILSTEAD | $13,000,000 | 3821 | $3,402 | FH |
THE CONTINUUM | $5,052,960 | 1690 | $2,990 | FH |
MEYER BLUE | $4,786,000 | 1528 | $3,131 | FH |
PINETREE HILL | $4,632,000 | 1733 | $2,673 | 99 yrs (2022) |
THE ORIE | $3,983,000 | 1453 | $2,741 | 99 yrs (2024) |
Top 5 Cheapest New Sales (By Project)
PROJECT NAME | PRICE S$ | AREA (SQFT) | $PSF | TENURE |
LENTOR CENTRAL RESIDENCES | $1,197,000 | 463 | $2,586 | 99 yrs (2023) |
NOVO PLACE | $1,398,000 | 872 | $1,603 | 99 yrs (2023) |
LUMINA GRAND | $1,418,000 | 936 | $1,514 | 99 yrs (2022) |
NORTH GAIA | $1,419,000 | 1033 | $1,373 | 99 yrs (2021) |
AURELLE OF TAMPINES | $1,434,000 | 840 | $1,708 | 99 years |
Top 5 Most Expensive Resale
PROJECT NAME | PRICE S$ | AREA (SQFT) | $PSF | TENURE |
LEEDON RESIDENCE | $16,000,000 | 6125 | $2,612 | FH |
THE CLAYMORE | $11,380,000 | 3348 | $3,399 | FH |
GOODWOOD RESIDENCE | $7,330,000 | 2454 | $2,987 | FH |
CUSCADEN RESERVE | $7,299,000 | 2099 | $3,477 | 99 yrs (2018) |
THE DRAYCOTT | $6,250,000 | 2637 | $2,370 | FH |
Top 5 Cheapest Resale
PROJECT NAME | PRICE S$ | AREA (SQFT) | $PSF | TENURE |
RIVERBAY | $640,000 | 388 | $1,652 | 999 yrs (1882) |
KOVAN GRANDEUR | $640,000 | 388 | $1,652 | 99 yrs (2010) |
8@WOODLEIGH | $680,000 | 398 | $1,707 | 99 yrs (2008) |
THE INFLORA | $682,000 | 463 | $1,473 | 99 yrs (2012) |
SKYSUITES17 | $718,000 | 355 | $2,021 | FH |
Top 5 Biggest Winners
PROJECT NAME | PRICE S$ | AREA (SQFT) | $PSF | RETURNS | HOLDING PERIOD |
THE CLAYMORE | $11,380,000 | 3348 | $3,399 | $6,370,000 | 26 Years |
THE REGALIA | $5,650,000 | 2648 | $2,134 | $4,270,000 | 21 Years |
LEEDON RESIDENCE | $16,000,000 | 6125 | $2,612 | $4,000,000 | 8 Years |
NEWTON 21 | $3,980,000 | 2411 | $1,651 | $2,270,000 | 19 Years |
TANGLIN PARK | $3,880,000 | 1507 | $2,575 | $2,250,000 | 25 Years |
Top 5 Biggest Losers
PROJECT NAME | PRICE S$ | AREA (SQFT) | $PSF | RETURNS | HOLDING PERIOD |
ORCHARD SCOTTS | $3,900,000 | 2282 | $1,709 | -$430,000 | 12 Years |
URBAN TREASURES | $1,000,000 | 517 | $1,935 | -$17,000 | 4 Years |
PINETREE HILL | $3,213,000 | 1292 | $2,487 | $0 | 5 Months |
THE ARDEN | $2,344,000 | 1410 | $1,662 | $0 | 2 Months |
PINETREE HILL | $2,056,000 | 797 | $2,581 | $0 | 1 Years |
Transaction Breakdown

For more on the Singapore property market, follow us on Stacked.
Ryan J
A seasoned content strategist with over 17 years in the real estate and financial journalism sectors, Ryan has built a reputation for transforming complex industry jargon into accessible knowledge. With a track record of writing and editing for leading financial platforms and publications, Ryan's expertise has been recognised across various media outlets. His role as a former content editor for 99.co and a co-host for CNA 938's Open House programme underscores his commitment to providing valuable insights into the property market.Read next from Singapore Property News

Singapore Property News Why This Rare New Queenstown Condo Nearly Sold Out Even At $2,800 Psf

Singapore Property News When ‘Fringe’ Homes Cross $2,000 PSF, Has Singapore’s Idea of ‘Prime’ Changed for Good?

Singapore Property News A Holland Village New Launch Just Sold 98.8% Of Its Units In One Weekend — Here’s Why Everyone Rushed In

Singapore Property News Why Old Run-Down Malls Make Neighbourhoods Better In Singapore
Latest Posts

Pro Are Older One- and Two-Bedders in District 21 Holding Up Against the New Launches? We Break It Down

Property Advice Most New Condo Buyers in Singapore Forget to Check This Before Buying (Until It’s Too Late)

On The Market Surprisingly Affordable 5 bedroom Condos You Can Buy Right Now Under $2.3 Million

Landed Home Tours I Toured A Rare Freehold Landed Street Where $5M Still Gets You A Proper Family Home

On The Market Four Rare Penthouses Overlooking Jurong Lake Gardens On The Market From $4.38m – Each With Over 2,000 Sqft Of Space

New Launch Condo Analysis Singapore’s First W Hotel–Branded Condo Launches From $3,230 PSF in Marina Bay: Here’s What You Need To Know

On The Market The Cheapest 4-Room HDB Flats in Central Singapore You Can Still Buy Under $520K

New Launch Condo Analysis Zyon Grand Pricing Review: How It Compares To Nearby Resale And New Launches In River Valley

New Launch Condo Reviews Zyon Grand Condo Review: Integrated Condo With Direct MRT Access From $2,689 Psf

BTO Reviews October 2025 BTO Launch Review: Ultimate Guide To Choosing The Best Unit

Pro Are Older Three- and Four-Bedders in District 10 Holding Up Against the New Launches? We Break It Down

On The Market 5 Rare HDB Flats Above 1,700 Sq ft You Can Buy Right Now In 2025

Landed Home Tours We Toured A Landed Street Near One Of Singapore’s Most Sought-After Schools — Where A Home Last Sold For $32 Million

Editor's Pick Where Singaporeans Can Still Buy A City Apartment For $184,000 — And Earn 5% Rental Yield. But Should You?

On The Market The Cheapest 4-Bedroom Condos You Can Buy in Singapore Right Now From $1.39M
