Around this time last year, National Development Minister Lawrence Wong cautioned resale HDB flat buyers that not all old HDB flats will automatically be eligible for the Selective En bloc Redevelopment Scheme (SERS).
<Leasehold Properties as Assets> My last blog on choosing a HDB resale flat generated some discussion and debate. Let…
Posted by Lawrence Wong on Tuesday, April 11, 2017
This sparked a huge debate online and prompted a follow up, with the National Development Minister saying that leasehold properties are still a good store of asset value. Many people are still divided over whether an HDB flat should be seen as an asset or just a home. This is partly because the “Asset Enhancement Scheme“, which was a theme of the PAP back in the 1990s. As such, many of the older generation still believe that an HDB flat is an asset that is a wise investment and in local terms in Singapore, “confirm won’t lose money!” So how does this actually affect the HDB resale price?
HDB flat an asset or liability?
Of course properties in general will always be seen as an asset. It is easy to see why many Singaporeans have such faith in the property market in Singapore, where in 1986 to 1996 there was a 440% increase in the private residential price index. Many Singaporeans also made bucket loads of cash in the 2006-2007 en bloc frenzy, with the current en bloc cycle in 2018 still riding high.
However, Singapore is no longer a developing nation and growth in the economy is not going to be as rapid as before. In fact, despite the projected increase in property price in Singapore, the resale prices actually declined by 0.8% in Q1 2018.
So what will I be looking to see in terms of my HDB resale price?
Although new flats used to be pegged to the HDB resale price, this is no longer the practice today. So since this move in 2011, the prices of a new BTO flat has become more affordable. In general, buying a BTO flat will always be an attractive option, due to the subsidised rates and many housing grants that are available. You will have to contend with certain inconveniences at the beginning, such as the wait for the flat to be built and the availability of amenities. For example, in the earlier years of Punggol’s history, BTO prices were really low to attract people to purchase flats there as there were hardly any amenities in the area at that point. But once the supply was ramped up and malls such as Waterway Point were established, the HDB resale price in Punggol has gone up.
So let us take a look at 3 areas that have been quite popular with younger Singaporeans, Bukit Panjang, Punggol and Sengkang.
Bukit Panjang 3-room BTO

In Bukit Panjang if you had bought a BTO in 2008, the price range of a 3-room BTO was between $138,000 to $170,000. As of 2017 last year, the HDB resale price range was between $315,000 to $345,000. This is a 114% increase in less than 10 years!
Bukit Panjang 4-room BTO

If you had bought a 4-room BTO in 2008, the price range was between $211,000 to $270,000. As of 2017 last year, the HDB resale price range was between $400,000 to $480,000. This is a 82% increase in less than 10 years!
Punggol 3-room BTO

In Punggol if you had bought a BTO in 2008, the price range of a 3-room BTO was between $135,000 to $211,000. As of 2017 last year, the HDB resale price range was between $345,000 to $420,000. This is a 121% increase in less than 10 years!
Punggol 4-room BTO

If you had bought a 4-room BTO in 2008, the price range was between $223,000 to $327,000. As of 2017 last year, the HDB resale price range was between $361,888 to $580,000. This is a 71% increase in less than 10 years!
Punggol 5-room BTO

If you had bought a 5-room BTO in 2008, the price range was between $305,000 to $428,000. As of 2017 last year, the HDB resale price range was between $470,000 to $860,000. This is a 81% increase in less than 10 years!

Property TrendsWe Analysed 22 Recent HDB MOP Estates To Find Out Which Has Made The Most Money
by ReubenSengkang 3-room BTO

In Sengkang if you had bought a BTO in 2008, the price range of a 3-room BTO was between $120,000 to $162,000. As of 2017 last year, the HDB resale price range was between $335,000 to $378,000. That is a whopping 152% increase in less than 10 years!
Sengkang 4-room BTO

If you had bought a 4-room BTO in 2008, the price range was between $190,000 to $275,000. As of 2017 last year, the HDB resale price range was between $380,000 to $470,000. This is a 82% increase in less than 10 years!
Sengkang 5-room BTO

If you had bought a 5-room BTO in 2008, the price range was between $290,000 to $367,000. As of 2017 last year, the HDB resale price range was between $500,000 to $580,000. This is a 64% increase in less than 10 years!
From these figures you can easily see that a Sengkang 3-room HDB is the biggest winner here, nearly doubling most of the returns from the other estates if you were to compare with the 4-room and 5-room. Of course, the increases are impressive for the 3-room HDBs, but it was always to be expected given the lower value of the home. Also, don’t forget that these are probably one of the higher growth HDB estates around.
If you would like us to expand on more estates, you can always contact us at hello@stackedhomes.com! Or feel free to leave a comment down below.
Sean
Sean has a writing experience of 3 years and is currently with Stacked Homes focused on general property research, helping to pen articles focused on condos. In his free time, he enjoys photography and coffee tasting.Read next from Property Advice

Property Advice We Ranked The Most Important Things To Consider Before Buying A Property In Singapore: This One Came Top

Property Advice Why Punggol Northshore Could Be The Next Hotspot In The HDB Resale Market

Property Advice How Much Is Your Home Really Worth? How Property Valuations Work in Singapore

Property Advice Why I Had Second Thoughts After Buying My Dream Home In Singapore
Latest Posts

New Launch Condo Analysis Springleaf Residence Pricing Review: How It Compares To Nearby Resale And New Launches

New Launch Condo Reviews Springleaf Residence Review: A 941 Mega-Development Near The MRT From $1,995 Psf

Property Market Commentary 4 Condo Layouts And Features Buyers Are Moving Away From in 2025

Editor's Pick Summer Suites Condo Review: A Freehold Johor Bahru Condo Near The RTS Link

Pro New Launch vs Resale Condos in District 9: Which Bedroom Types Offer Better Value Today?

Editor's Pick Over 900 Units Sold in One Weekend: The Surprising Lessons From River Green, Promenade Peak & Canberra Crescent

Singapore Property News Is Property Decoupling To Avoid ABSD Now Illegal?

Editor's Pick I Visited Freehold Terraces, Semi-Ds, and Detached Homes in the East Ranging from $2.5 Million to $11 Million

Singapore Property News How Condo Buying In Singapore Became A Game Of Luck

Editor's Pick Springleaf Residence Launches From $878K — Is This 941-Unit Mega Development Worth It?

On The Market 5 Spacious 3-Bedroom Condos That Cost Less Than You’d Expect (Under $2M)

Singapore Property News Is Your HDB or Condo at Risk of a Sinkhole? 5 Signs to Watch Out For

New Launch Condo Analysis Canberra Crescent Residences Pricing Breakdown: A Price Comparison With Nearby Condos

Property Market Commentary 10 Most Affordable New Launch Condos Under $1.5 Million—Some Are Surprisingly Central

Editor's Pick Why I Might Still Pay $1 Million For A 50-Year-Old HDB—Even If Everyone Says It’s A Bad Buy
