The Impact Of High Land Prices On Singapore’s Property Prices: How Land Prices Have Moved Since 1992
One of the main reasons cited by developers, as to why new launch prices are so high, is the price of land. We have an article that covers some of the details here. However, a common criticism we’ve heard from many of you is that you seem to hear this every year; and granted, we’re hard-pressed to find a time when developers weren’t complaining about land prices. So we decided have a look back at how land prices have been rising:
How have land prices moved in Singapore?
This shows the average land prices since 1992. You’ll notice three big spikes here:
The first, in around 1996, was when there were huge run-ups in prices in the years before; right up to around mid-1997. This was the prelude to the Asian Financial Crisis (AFC), when the market was exuberant before the sudden crash. When the plunge began in mid’97, it resulted in one of the worst-ever property downturns, with some home prices falling around 45 per cent from the 1996 peak (you can read about it in this old document).
The second, in around 2007, came on the back of a major property boom. Right the next year though, the Global Financial Crisis sent prices plummeting again. However, recovery was very fast-paced, thanks to a zero-interest rate policy set by the US Federal Reserve. At one point, the impact was so extreme, that borrowers using SOR loan packages (these are not used anymore today) actually had negative home loan interest rates.
The third great spike, which happened around 2017, is allegedly due to the influx of Chinese developers with deep pockets. This caused an en-bloc frenzy, with aggressive bidding that drove up land prices and depressed margins; and while Chinese developers have largely been accepted as a part of the landscape now, their impact on land prices has never quite been reversed.
2017 seemed to be the year that pushed up prices most significantly
If you look at the average land price in 2017, you’ll notice this is the first time we see the average go past $1,000 psf. This was about a spike of 34.5 per cent from the year before ($784 psf).
After 2017, we never again see land prices go below $1,000 psf, with one exception being the Covid-peak of 2020. The very next year, prices bounced right back past $1,000 psf.
At that point, the market was braced for a possible surge in prices; because by 2022 the last tranche of 2017 en-bloc redevelopments would be completed. But as we mentioned in this article, that never quite came to pass. A combination of more GLS land being released, higher ABSD, as well as Land Betterment Charges (LBC), caused developers to hesitate with any aggressive bids. Developer caution caused the price to dip to $1,061 psf last year; and if the recent bid for the Marina Gardens white site is any indication, land prices might continue to stay muted – at least in areas like the CCR, which are most impacted by cooling measures.
So in the immediate sense, land prices are a bit lower compared to the past two years.
But if that’s the case, why don’t new launch prices drop?
Well, ever since last year, it’s become established that the “norm” for a new launch is around $2,100+ psf. So even if a developer can get the land for cheaper, they will likely never go below this pricing. Why would they? If buyers are still biting at that price, and the market accepts it, then developers are eager to improve their already-thin margins.
In a related discussion with a realtor this week, she pointed out that – just because a consortium got the Marina Gardens white site for a lower bid – that doesn’t mean the resulting project is going to be much cheaper than surrounding condos. It’s expected that new launches will be priced higher than existing resale projects; and the existing projects there – such as Marina One or Marina Bay Residences – are far from cheap.
As such, land prices do impact developer pricing; but there are other “sticky” factors, like established market rates, that can keep prices high regardless of whether land is cheaper that year.
There is one other factor to consider: en-bloc sales and the cost of a replacement property
This is a bit of a wild card in the coming years, as we don’t know how the en-bloc market is now going to play out. On the one hand, it would seem that en-bloc sellers are going to push for much higher prices, given the cost of a replacement property.
If you bought a resale home in January 2014, for example, it may have cost around $1,204 psf. If that home goes en-bloc and you need a replacement property, a resale unit right now averages about $1,595 psf, whilst a new launch averages around $2,315 psf.
It’s a rather huge sum a prospective developer has to offer, to convince you to sign off on the collective sale; and this would drive up land prices again.
On the flip side, the en-bloc sellers may flinch first, and agree to come down on prices since developers are more cautious. It may seem that most people don’t have an urgent need to sell, however, as most Singaporean property owners are well-capitalised and can wait till they see the price they want.
That said, we are already seeing signs that owners will have to come down on those prices as the developers are not biting. One big example is Pine Grove, where the en-bloc sale committee is trying to get a common consensus to relaunch at a lower price of $1.78 billion, instead of the earlier $1.95 billion.
Overall, it’s likely that we won’t see another 2017 en-bloc frenzy, not with the current economic conditions, interest rates, and cooling measures; but while this means land prices aren’t likely to spike, it doesn’t guarantee lower new launch prices either.
For more on the situation as it unfolds, follow us on Stacked. We also provide in-depth reviews of new and resale properties alike. If you’d like to get in touch for a more in-depth consultation, you can do so here.
