HDBWhere Do These Million-dollar Flats Keep Coming From?
- by Ryan J Ong
- November 13, 2020
- 8 min read
It is quite crazy if you were to think about it. The very first HDB flat to hit this magical million dollar mark was an executive apartment at Block 149 Mei Ling Street in Queenstown. This unit was sold for $1 million in 2012.
Now in October 2020, even with the Covid-19 pandemic hanging over our heads, 13 HDB resale flats were sold for more than $1 million – the highest ever number of transactions in a month.
In this article, that’s what we’re taking a look at: the million-dollar flats that have effectively minted money for their owners. We know they’re outliers – but nonetheless, it is still an interesting topic:
Again, around 13 flats were sold for $1 million+ in October 2020
This is the first time we’ve seen so many million-dollar HDB flats in a single month, breaking the previous record of 11 transactions (June 2018). In total, 59 resale flats have been sold at the $1 million mark between January to October.
This is on the back of an overall surge in resale flat prices, which are now rising at their fastest pace in eight years. It seems that it took a global pandemic to finally make the HDB resale market change course, after near-continuous decline since 2013.
These are the 13 flats for the record-breaking month:
Note that unfortunately, we have no records of the flats’ initial purchase price
|Address||Lease Start||Flat Size (Sq. Ft)||Notable Details||Price (PSF)||Total Price|
|275A Bishan St 24||2011||5-room 1292 sq. ft.||DBSS||$935||$1,208,000.00|
|9A Boon Tiong Rd||2016||5-room 1206 sq. ft.||–||$956||$1,153,000.00|
|1F Cantonment Rd||2011||5-room 1130 sq. ft.||–||$1,018||$1,150,000.00|
|173 Bishan St 13||1987||Exec 1755 sq. ft.||Maisonette||$643||$1,128,000.00|
|18C Holland Dr||2012||5-room 1259 sq. ft.||–||$873||$1,100,000.00|
|9A Boon Tiong Rd||2016||5-room 1206 sq. ft.||–||$904||$1,090,000.00|
|1G Cantonment Rd||2011||5-room 1130 sq. ft.||–||$956||$1,080,000.00|
|1G Cantonment Rd||2011||4-room 1001 sq. ft.||–||$1,069||$1,070,000.00|
|138A Lor 1A Toa Payoh||2012||5-room 1259 sq. ft.||DBSS||$849||$1,068,888.00|
|9A Boon Tiong Rd||2016||5-room 1206 sq. ft.||–||$863||$1,040,000.00|
|1A Cantonment Rd||2011||4-room 1001 sq. ft.||–||$1,029||$1,030,000.00|
|95C Henderson Rd||2019||–||$999||$1,000,000.00|
|148 Mei Ling St||1995||Exec 1615 sq. ft.||–||$619||$1,000,000.00|
As there are limits to what you can tell from one month, we also checked out the top 10 highest resale flat transactions, from 2019 to the present.
Note that these are in addition to the October transactions above. Unfortunately, we don’t have the lease start dates for the following.
In order of most to least expensive, these are:
|Transaction date||Address||Flat size (Sq. ft.)||Notable details||Price (psf)||Total price|
|July 2019||Blk 148 Mei Ling Street||Exec. 1,582||–||$727||$1,150,000|
|March 2019||Blk 173 Bishan Street 13||Exec.1,754||Maisonette||$653||$1,450,000|
|August 2020||Blk 43 Moh Guan Terrace||4-room1,410||Adjoined flat||$772||$1,088,000|
|September 2020||Blk 149 Mei Ling Street||Exec. 1,614||–||$668||$1,078,000|
|July 2019||Blk 148 Mei Ling Street||Exec.1,582||–||$673||$1,065,000|
|July 2020||Blk 148 Mei Ling Street||Exec.1,603||–||$658||$1,055,000|
|September 2020||Blk 245 Bishan Street 22||Exec.1,657||Maisonette||$631||$1,044,888|
|March 2020||Blk 148 Mei Ling Street||Exec.1,560||–||$660||$1,030,000|
|January 2020||Blk 99 B Toa Payoh Avenue 2||Exec.1,550||–||$661||$1,025,000|
|April 2019||Blk 168 Bishan Street 13||Exec.1,754||Maisonette||$575||$1,008,000|
What are the traits these flats share?
- The flats are all in central locations
- Most of the flats are huge by today’s standards
- DBSS and Maisonettes continue to make their presence felt
- Million-dollar flats remain outliers
1. The flats are all in central locations
You’re probably wondering, at this point, where Mei Ling Street is and what makes it so special.
Mei Ling Street is located in Queenstown, one of Singapore’s oldest HDB towns. The famous Block 148 (which you see repeatedly appearing in the list above) is just 550 metres from the Queenstown MRT station via Stirling Walk (about seven minutes away). It’s about a 10-minute drive to Orchard Road.
The Cantonment Road address is the famed Pinnacle @ Duxton, a unique 50-storey HDB development (contrary to popular belief, this is not a DBSS flat; it is just a special, one-off development). It’s located in Tanjong Pagar, close to the heart of the CBD.
Boon Tiong Road is in Tiong Bahru, an old but gentrified hipster district; and Toa Payoh and Bishan probably need no introduction; these are mature, central towns where demand has always been high.
Note that the central location somewhat offsets the drawbacks of age, for some of the older flats. Given their prime location, they’re more likely to be targeted for exercises like the Selective En-bloc Redevelopment Scheme (SERS); or they may be picked by retirees downsizing from private property; such buyers can afford to pay for the convenience of a central location, and don’t particularly care about lease decay or resale profits.
2. Most of the flats are huge by today’s standards
The average size of a 5-room flat today is about 1,184 sq. ft., while 4-room flats average 969 sq. ft. From the list above, you can see most of the flats (barring the ones at Pinnacle @ Duxton) are huge compared to the norm. As such, it’s likely that many of them were older flats, built in the 1990’s or before.
In particular, note that Maisonettes are two-storey units; some can go up to 2,300+ sq. ft.
The size makes them appealing to extended families, who sometimes pool their resources to afford a larger, top-end flat.
3. DBSS and Maisonettes continue to make their presence felt
Simple scarcity helps to elevate the prices of these units. Maisonettes, as mentioned above, are no longer produced; the last of them were built in 1995. They’re properly called Executive Maisonettes (EM), and they were the predecessors to today’s Executive Condominiums (ECs).
The Design, Build, and Sell Scheme (DBSS) was started in 2005. These flats have a higher quality of finishing, and are constructed by private developers. However, they’re not the same as ECs; they lack full-suite condo facilities like gyms, pools, and so forth. They’re also never privatised, and remain HDB flats throughout. In essence, they’re more upmarket HDB flats.
Trivelis in Clementi, The Peak @ Toa Payoh (Lorong 1 A Toa Payoh on the list above), and Natura Loft in Bishan (Bishan Street 24 on the list above) are some of the most famous examples.
To date, Pinnacle @ Duxton accounts for about 25 transactions that meet the million-dollar mark.
These types of flats cater well to right-sizing buyers, who don’t want to shift all the way from private property down to a regular flat. They may also be chosen by some buyers who have just come into an inheritance, are beneficiaries of insurance policies, etc. If the amount they receive is about $800,000, for instance, it may not go far in the condo market – but it’s sufficient to comfortably buy a huge DBSS flat, or a resale flat with a great view of the downtown area (Pinnacle @ Duxton).
4. Million-dollar flats remain outliers
Million-dollar flats make up a tiny 0.3 per cent of HDB flat transactions. They’re outliers, and all the traits above reflect that: these flats tend to be special developments like Maisonettes, DBSS flats, etc., or are among the handful of flats in Singapore’s central region.
However, there’s no denying that the number of these outliers is growing at a furious pace; from just two in 2014, to 72 last year. With over a 35-fold increase in just six years, resale flats may well become a two-speed market in the next decade or two; one where central region flats are a whole segment apart from “regular” HDB flats.
What does it take to buy a million-dollar flat?
The ability to stomach sky-high Cash Over Valuation (COV).
COV refers to prices above the official valuation by HDB. This amount is not covered by the home loan, and must be paid in cash. COV numbers are no longer recorded or publicised, but they almost definitely exist for million-dollar flats. The first ever million-dollar flat in 2012 (on Mei Ling Street) was known to have transacted with a COV of $195,000. The second million-dollar flat (in Bishan) saw a COV of $250,000.
Do remember, you need to agree on the price and secure the Option to Purchase, before HDB will tell you the valuation; so you won’t fully know what to expect. You should be prepared with extra funds.
Million-dollar flats shouldn’t be taken as a reflection of the overall HDB market
There’s no need to panic; you and your children won’t be priced out of the resale market. While the number of million-dollar flats are likely to grow, they still don’t reflect the price movements of the resale flat market; they’re peculiarities, not points of reference (unless you live on Mei Ling Street).
For a look at the wider property market, follow us on Stacked. We’ll update you with the latest news and happenings in Singapore real estate, as well as provide in-depth review of local properties.