Commentary

We Tried To Eliminate Property Agents In Singapore: Why We Failed & The Challenges New Platforms Face

Join our Telegram group for instant notifications
Join Now

Ryan J

A seasoned content strategist with over 17 years in the real estate and financial journalism sectors, Ryan has built a reputation for transforming complex industry jargon into accessible knowledge. With a track record of writing and editing for leading financial platforms and publications, Ryan’s expertise has been recognised across various media outlets. His role as a former content editor for 99.co and a co-host for CNA 938’s Open House programme underscores his commitment to providing valuable insights into the property market.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
14 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
William
William
1 year ago

Appreciate the honest evaluation of the market and your platform. That said, how do buyers deal with the inherent conflict of interest with their agents? (ie. their agent’s commission is on transacted value but a buyer would want to pay as low a price as possible)

Stacked Homes
Admin
1 year ago
Reply to  William

Great question. The biggest problem is really how do you ensure that the agent is incentivised to find you the right property and not one that they are paid the highest commission on. I’m less inclined to think that the commission on the transacted value is an issue, as it’s a factor that is hard to control (in the presence of many other interested buyers and higher bids).

Tzl
Tzl
1 year ago

Yes, I often feel we are just being manipulated into closing a deal as soon as possible. Also, quality of listings on propertyguru are just terrible.

Stacked Homes
Admin
1 year ago
Reply to  Tzl

Admittedly, that is a problem that’s hard to fix. It’s worth highlighting again that a lot of what we’ve said is based on finding a good agent that you can trust, the advice and experience is something that is hard to quantify.

Also yes! the listings are terrible. It’s also a matter in the past few years that seller agents didn’t have to work as hard to sell properties. Buyers would come irrespective of how shitty the listing is. At the end of the day, it’s always a cycle and the time will come soon where there would be more sellers than buyers, and more effort will have to be put in to attract buyers – better listings, better photos, more video, etc.

Bobby
Bobby
1 year ago

Agreed that because property transactions are high-value transactions that happen only once or twice in someone’s life, these transactions demand a high level of trust and personal touch that isn’t simply replaceable by machines. 

This naturally leads us to a vital question. How do we find good and trustworthy agents if there is a lack of information on agents and every agent’s profile seems to be roughly similar? 

Not sure if this is useful but BetterAgents SG is a property agent review platform where people can share their personal experiences with their property agent. Hopefully, with more people sharing their interactions with agents, this can introduce some transparency for other Singaporeans looking to engage property agents. 

Stacked Homes
Admin
1 year ago
Reply to  Bobby

It’ll be great to have such a platform! But it seems like something that will be hard to grow. Naturally agents that don’t have good reviews will not want to be on such a platform, and it looks like there will be a lot of moderation involved to ensure that reviews are not faked, or disputes over a bad review from an agent that may not be real. And if there’s no monetisation strategy in place at the moment, who would be doing this work?

Ultimately too, if there aren’t enough buyers coming on to use it there’s little incentive for agents to push such a platform if they aren’t getting enough referrals from it too.

Rick
Rick
1 year ago

Used the site before.
One key reason imo was it was not user-friendly and technologically outdated and slow.

Stacked Homes
Admin
1 year ago
Reply to  Rick

That’s fair criticism! We aren’t sure when you last used it, but we wanted to first prove that there was a market for this that could grow, before trying to improve the other aspects of the process.

Yoda
Yoda
1 year ago

Great article and good insights. Thanks for sharing. Most and if not all of the challenges you raised can be solved with technology, create a win-win-win situation for sellers-buyers-agents, and these platforms should work. Airbnb works. and http://www.zillow.com works.

Stacked Homes
Admin
1 year ago
Reply to  Yoda

Thanks for the kind words! Well, these platforms also work because they have a much larger audience, and there’s greater incentive to put in the money to make it work. Unfortunately, the same can’t be said for Singapore!

Jenson Chan
Jenson Chan
1 year ago

Stacked didn’t manage to eliminate property agents, but you have successfully pivoted to provide the best property analysis and insights (importantly impartial) for readers. Cheers!

Stacked Homes
Admin
1 year ago
Reply to  Jenson Chan

Really appreciate the kind words! Yeah, it was apparent after going into content that there was a real need for buyers to have access to good analysis and insights – it’s been a really interesting journey so far!

james
james
1 year ago
Reply to  Stacked Homes

glad you moved into property content – the precious insights are what me and my wife love to read and unbiased content like this is truly hard to find!

Yasser Khan
Yasser Khan
11 months ago

Absolutely on point. I agree that realtors are not going to be replaced anytime soon as most people have a real fear even though they complain a lot about agents.

Latest Posts

Inside A 110sqm Cave Like Apartment For A Family Of Three 1
Living In Inside A 110sqm Cave-Like Apartment For A Family Of Three
November 14, 2024
5 Cheapest 4 Room HDB Flats In Central Singapore From $480k
Units Of The Week 5 Cheapest 4-Room HDB Flats In Central Singapore From $480k
November 14, 2024
cluster housing
Property Picks 10 Cheapest Cluster Landed Homes In Singapore From $1,840,000
November 13, 2024
BTO flats
BTO 7 Top Tips For First-Time BTO Buyers: What You Need To Consider In 2024
November 13, 2024
Clement Canopy price review
Property Picks 5 Noteworthy Condos In Clementi: Why This ‘Fringe’ Area Is Now A Property Hotspot
November 11, 2024
Urban Vista and The Enclave Holland
Property Picks Where To Find The Cheapest Resale Condos By Bedroom Type In 2024 (From $545,000)
November 11, 2024
Prince of Wales 25
Editors' Pick Touring An Expensive Landed Estate In Bukit Timah: Freehold And 999-Year Homes Near Nanyang Primary From $9.5m
November 10, 2024
How Much Do You Really Need To Comfortably Buy A 3 room HDB As A Single In 2024
News Why This New HDB Rule Is A Big Win For Singles (After Years Of Being Overlooked)
November 10, 2024
A Family's 1950s Mid Century Restored Home With Curated Artwork | Singapore
Living In A Family’s 1950s Mid-Century Restored Home With Curated Artwork
November 10, 2024
Emerald of Katong Pricing Review
Analysis Is Emerald Of Katong Really A Good Buy? A Detailed Look At Pricing Vs Tembusu Grand And D15 Competitors
November 9, 2024
Union Square Model 49
Editors' Pick Union Square Residences Review: A Lifestyle Mixed-Use Project In Clarke Quay Priced From $1.38m
November 9, 2024
5. Emerald of Katong Model 25
Editors' Pick Emerald Of Katong Condo Review: Competitive Entry Prices In District 15 And Efficient Layouts
November 8, 2024
Ground Floor Condo Big Space Floor Plan
Property Picks Where To Find The Biggest And Cheapest Condo Units In 2024 (From $1,360,000)
November 8, 2024
Inside A 65 Sqm Home Designed For Open Concept Living With Views Of Nature | Singapore
Living In Inside A 65 Sqm Home Designed For Open-Concept Living With Views Of Nature
November 7, 2024
Feb BTO 2024 Exercise
BTO We Review The February 2025 BTO Launch Sites (Kallang/Whampoa, Queenstown, Woodlands, Yishun)
November 7, 2024
5 Cheapest 4 Bedroom Condos Under $1.6M In 2024
Units Of The Week 5 Cheapest 4-Bedroom Condos Under $1.6M In 2024
November 7, 2024