Property Stories I Nearly Bought A Condo With A Ceiling Leak & Depleting Sinking Fund Issue: Why MCST Problems Need To Be More Transparent

  • October 17, 2022
  • 11 min read
Join our Telegram group for instant notifications
Join Now

Ryan J

Ryan is an old school print journalist gone digital. He's lived in almost every type of housing in Singapore, from flats to landed homes. Over the past 18 years, he's been a content developer for companies large and small, a co-founder in an education business, and sometimes a voice on the radio. He also spends too much time and money on painting little plastic soldiers.

avatar
Swn4
Swn4

What also surprises me is that monthly mcst fees (maintenance & sinking funds) are not std info in property listings

Stacked Homes
Stacked Homes

We agree, we think this should change. Some agents do indicate the MCST fees, but most listings do not have them.

Aaron
Aaron

Good article and timely

Stacked Homes
Stacked Homes

Thank you!

San
San

This article is published very timely. Especially with the escalating prices of property and the resistance of old school owners who tend to be part of MC, it gets harder for potential buyers to get full disclosure of any information from the property agent. Maybe STACKED can start a forum and be the voice of potential buyers or even sellers when it comes to MCST disputes and how to handle them. Perhaps getting speakers from the respective authorities would help to clarify many questions that I am sure many owners and buyers would like answered.

contrarian
contrarian

May I suggest that you spend time studying the BMSMA and BMSMR and write another article correcting the misinformation in this one?
The law and regulation already makes the items you mention transparent, including to prospective buyers.
S47 specifically allows a prospective buyer to require an MCST to produce the info stated there, including the minutes of the AGM and the statement of accounts, by paying the fee. S38 specifies how the MCST can use the management fund or not.
You might also consider interviewing some experts, lawyers, managing agents or council members to improve your knowledge on MCSTs and councils.

Passer-by
Passer-by

This is very interesting. Yes an article on how s47 works might be very useful. If the fee isn’t large, then I don’t see why it isn’t a standard practice for all prospective buyers to purchase such information. If anyone has experience using s47, please share for our knowledge thank you, including how much the prescribed fee tends to be.

contrarian
contrarian

The fee is stated in Regulation 11 of the BMSMR.

Stacked Homes
Stacked Homes

Hi contrarian, thanks for taking the time to provide insights into this matter here. We’ve spoken to BCA directly and have made the changes above. While it is true that the law makes it clear that such documents must be handed over for a fee when requested, buyers still face the uphill battle of obtaining it – either through MCST’s ignorance or laziness in providing such information. The problem on the ground is that it then falls on the buyer to take more action which can be frustrating especially in this market condition where sellers have the upper hand. Nonetheless,… Read more »

Joseph
Joseph

Since when did authorities like COB vet certified true copies of audited accounts of MCSTs every year? I hope your next article corrects some of these points made, especially with reference to the BMSMA. An accredited strata manager or lawyer should know better.

Stacked Homes
Stacked Homes

Hi Joseph, thanks for sharing your thoughts on this. We’ve spoken to BCA and have made the corrections above. We’ll continue to work with them in providing more information to our readers.

Frieda Lee
Frieda Lee

If the MCST council is made up of owners who are property agents (owning 2 or more units) who rent out their residential for income, director from contractor/renovation firms, or shop operators (from mixed strata estates) you are likely to be disadvantaged in many ways.

Frieda Lee
Frieda Lee

It is very important to have the monthly financial statements bought which I have been buying for the past 4 years. It is the only way to question why levies are to be collected for improper expenditures on maintaining the estate building. I am surprised to note that Condo only imposes 15 per cent per annum in late payment, ours stay at 24 per cent per annum since I came back to stay in this old, walk-up apartment in late 2002.

Stacked Homes
Stacked Homes

Thanks for sharing your experience Frieda!

Jennifer
Jennifer

I am very interested on topics of MCST which are very seldom discussed.
Most of us are not well taught on the financials of buildings maintenance and sinking funds.
It would be very helpful ongoing topics!
Love it. Thank you stackedhomes!

Stacked Homes
Stacked Homes

Welcome! We hope to shed more light on this topic as we speak to more people about it!

Latest Posts

taobao regrets
Interior “I Regret Buying From Taobao” 5 Homeowners Share Their Worst Renovation Regrets
December 5, 2022
high park residences LRT
Investment 6 Things Foreign Investors Are Seldom Told About The Singapore Property Market
December 5, 2022
Joo Chiat Shophouse 3
Living In Inside A Modern Peranakan Shophouse With A Beautiful Courtyard Garden
December 4, 2022
thekimsresidence 5
Interior Tour A 4-Storey Multi-Generational Home Transformation: How A Couple Mixed An Aussie Aesthetic With Japandi Style
December 2, 2022
condo vs hdb
Advice We Have $500k In Cash And Looking To Buy Our First Home. Should We Buy A Resale HDB And Upgrade Later Or Buy A Condo First?
December 2, 2022
Aiken Reuben Tour The Coolest Hidden Bar In Singapore
Tastemakers Aiken & Reuben Tour The Coolest Hidden Bar In Singapore
December 2, 2022
Touring A 80k Renovated 2 Bedroom Home With Sea Views
Insider Tour Touring A $80k Renovated 2 Bedroom Home With Sea Views
December 1, 2022
Hyde condo
Insider Tour Unexpectedly Gorgeous Rooftop Views At The Hyde: Inside A Boutique District 10 Condo
December 1, 2022
5 Tastefully Renovated Penthouses That Are Ready To Move In
Units Of The Week 5 Tastefully Renovated Penthouses That Are Ready To Move In
December 1, 2022
agent friend
Commentary 6 Reasons Why You May Want To Avoid A Friend/Family As An Agent
November 30, 2022
A Hidden Wellness Club Most People Dont Know About
Tastemakers A Hidden Wellness Club Most People Don’t Know About
November 30, 2022
floridian condo lift lobby
Commentary We Spoke To BCA To Clear Common Property Misconceptions In Singapore: Here Are 9 You Need To Know
November 29, 2022
This Man Turned Waste Materials Into DIY Furniture For His HDB
Living In This Man Turned Waste Materials Into DIY Furniture For His HDB
November 29, 2022
biggest price increase hdb private
Commentary Cheapest Condos And HDBs In Singapore: Here’s How Much Prices Have Risen Since 2020
November 28, 2022
HanselStudio02
Interior Tour A Mid-Century Modern HDB Home In Cantonment Close That Doubles As A Private Dining Space
November 28, 2022
Inside A Dreamy Remake Of A 1970s Home With A Sky Lit Atrium
Living In Inside A Dreamy Remake Of A 1970s Home With A Sky-Lit Atrium
November 27, 2022